A Journalist's First iPhone Video - Critiqued

Posted December 10, 2015
Share To
 
 

Navtej Johal (@navtejhohal) is a TV reporter with the BBC’s East Midlands Today, their regional news show.


This is the first news piece he ever shot with an iPhone.


As you can see, the quality of the video is astonishingly good.  And for a first piece, it’s also pretty good.   I read about him on twitter and immediately asked if he would mind if I critiqued the piece on TheVJ.com.  He said, ‘no problem’.  I told him that critiques (my critiques at any rate) were both praise and criticism (that’s why we call them critique).  As we say at our video bootcamps, ‘if you want praise, show it to your mother.’

Overall, it’s pretty good, but take a look yourself and you can decide.

This video runs pretty long.  We’ll look at the piece as a whole, then I will go back and take it apart – the good, the bad and the ugly (or rather, those thing he could have done better, at least in my opinion).

 


Recent Posts

TV News’ Original Sin
January 08, 2025

My mentor in the television business was Fred Friendly. For those who never heard of him, he pretty much invented TV news. He was Edward R. Murrow’s producer for many years before he became President of CBS News.


In today’s digital era, platforms like YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram dominate our online lives with content created by influencers and creators making a lot of money with the videos they make. It’s easy to see why this is such an attractive career.


Local TV news is also in trouble. Viewership is down and the all-important younger demographic is not even interested in watching. How can we get them watching?


Share Page on: